Opinions

Will London Talks dismantle Somaliland Stability?

June 22, 2012   ·   24 Comments

Somalia and Somaliland meet in Chevening House in 2012

OPINION | JUNE 22, 2012

By Abdirahman Mohamed Dirye

In 21 years since Abdirahman Tuur created Somaliland, a nation without recognition under duress, he made a brick without straw. Somaliland born out of armed bloody struggle that lasted almost decade from 1981 to 1991 with the disappearance of Somalia. Thousands of combatants lost their lives during the deadly war to liberate Somaliland. The founder as well as the first president and the last chairman of Somali National Movement knew the possible repercussions and forewarned the inherent dangers of any unilateral declaration that come with the secession: the dire consequences, the inevitable isolation and the subsequent suffering; therefore, he tried to change the course after realizing how difficult to get Somaliland recognized, but naysayers mobilized the masses against his ideal principles whereby they instigated a deadly civil war that foiled his mission in 1994. But leaders go off in new direction when things do not work out as planned. Anyone in his circumstance would do the same thing.

We have been fighting for nationhood over the 21 years ; quarter of Somaliland population have died as result of gunshot or its aftermath, and many others maimed , on the other hand Somalia had fought to keep Somalia’s integrity intact but eventually plunged into ocean of blood and chaos . Tsunami of starvation and terrorism followed by devastating civil war of religious dimension and all these factors made the territorial unity of Somalia a joke.

However, Somaliland ultimately won and captured its territories, though a political war of securing political recognition seems a pipedream. However, the said talks underway in London if aimed at restoring Somalia unity, are nonsense, simply, it does not make sense to lose thousands of our beloved people in the fight and then back to square one: negotiating to join Mogadishu whose paradise destruction was solely blamed on us. Somali National Movement (SNM) triggered the ongoing crisis in Somalia for instance besides the drivers of religious curse there.

It is quite obvious to me and probably to anyone else that President Sheikh Sharif who believe the godly-union of Muslim Ummah , utopia of some kind, but conceded due to reasons we know after he was bombed back to Mogadishu after so many lonely days in the wild beast caves near Kismaayo, Somalia. It is also clear to us all that neither Somaliland nor Somalia would sit down the negotiation table until the other made startling concession: so either Somaliland conceded sovereignty or Somalia ignored the begging pleas calling the territorial unity of Somalia, a thing of past, nevertheless; Somaliland said it will never talk Somalia unless its sovereignty is respected, so Somalia might abandoned its rigid position of irrelevance. Somaliland will never yield to outside pressure.

Moreover, Somaliland negotiators are not the right ones to talk on our behalf: a bunch of men from the diasporas and with the foreign passport are leading high level talks. Somaliland suffering people need someone whose blood is shed for the freedom they enjoy today. Besides, Somaliland delegates must grieved for and wept for the orphans whose father responded to the outcry of their people and widows whose husbands died for our cause. Does Dr Abdilahi Omar or Hirsi Gab or Faysal Warabe, members of the delegation, meet this criteria? Absolutely no, what bilateral talks are we offered when Esse Arab, Somalia TFG defense secretary, the only minister in the system from Somaliland was removed from the list?

After military campaigns of several surnames ranging from TFG to Puntland, SCC and to Khatumo proved futile, enemies developed new methods of destabilizing in Somaliland, Kashmir was taken over through mere signature of its governor, not force, the notion that Somaliland would be appeased when given a prime minister or president is totally myth. We will remain Somaliland and we have always been Somaliland.

We Somalilanders are not prepared to give up our dearly acquired freedom for free! We died for it, but that does not we hate Somalis but the regime the oppressed us all except the minority tribe whose survival rested on the crazy regime. However; many Somalis across the country celebrate 18 May and remember it as landmark day for all Somalis irrespective of their ethnicity. Exiled nationals returned to Somalia to celebrate the downfall of the regime, one of Africa’s most brutal regimes in the world, it was a moment of truth, a moment of contemplation and remembrance unless you are coward whose father died in defense of injustice and brutality that has gone.

The armed struggle was not against a certain tribe or group, the country is shared by all despite diverse ethnic s but the loyalty of the country is shared by all.
At this critical juncture, we Somalilanders must stand together against those who, from any tribe, who want to undermine what our beloved youth has died for – the freedom of the present and future generation.

Dirye is Somaliland Volunteer and Activist based in Addis Ababa. He can be reached at: mrdirye@gmail.com

By

Tags: , , , , , , ,


Readers Comments (24)

  1. ComeAgain says:

    NOPE! Landers are made of better stuff, hence our success! Failure is not an option! Too many of our people have died, have laid down the best years of their lives trying to build this country from nothing. Built it up when nothing was left, they didnt run to the west they stayed and picked up the peices. Picked up their lives, mended their minds, hearts, and mangled limbs!

  2. I have been in Somaliland for a week now having had numerous meetings. From my limited experience of the region i feel that Somalia has little to offer Somaliland at this stage. Why would a region that has obtained so much over the last few years, including a legitimate government, sacrifice its security to join the mess in Mogadishu? The simple answer is – it would not – no country would under the same circumstances.
    http://russwood.posterous.com/somaliland-security

    • Kayse says:

      Are you still there? Enjoy yourself and I'm glad people are nice to you but be aware of the kids and don't go out late at night. There are some thugs its not all safe like all places.

      My boys are there and speak fluent English, if you need someone to show you around, welcome or chill. None of them are British tho, more like yankees.

  3. Abdi1234 says:

    I agree with the author regarding the independence of Somaliland not being for compromise. However, I disagree on two points, firstly Abdirahman Tuur did not create Somaliland as he alluded and his views regarding Somaliland sovereignty are well known to all and he is being judged by Allah for what he did or didn't do.

    Secondly, the author brings his stature down by disagreeing with people because of their height and where they reside. All Somalilanders have made sacrifices for the independence of our country and patriotism must not be limited to few who claim to be the liberators, while it is well known that most of them were sitting in Addis and Dirirdhawe doing nothing.

    As someone who lost a brother and a dear nephew together with hundreds of extended family members in action ,I'm offended by this author. How dare he can exclude me and thousands of true Somalilanders.

    • salaxley boy says:

      Allah will not judge Tuur for his views on Somaliland. He will be judged on his character and his Islamnimo

      He will not be judged on what he "did or didn't do" regarding Somaliland. There is no Somaliland in the day of judgement

  4. ali says:

    How in The world talks will dismantle s/land region stability.Puntland have The some stability nothing effected on Them.

    This what happens when people isolated usualy person will develop schizoaffective disorder or paranoia.

    • Abdiwahab says:

      are you crazy or jealous of somaliland – somaliland is a separate country before 1960 and after 1991 we rejected you zoomalians lol you are suffering from bipolar disorder we are too good for you primates GOODBYE SOMALIA NEVER AGAIN

  5. Ibrahim says:

    Have been looking at some Somalia websites, they are not making much of this development. A lot of them have not even reported on this, seems they do not think it is an important step or that it is simply one region of Somalia coming back to the fold. As a Somalilander I welcome these talks but erge caution.

  6. osman5 says:

    ComeAgain, Abdi1234, russwood,

    you all made good points, just add my 2 cents opinion to the mix. Somaliland will never accept in reuniting with Somali.
    It's like commiting a big mortgage without having any rights of the property you've been asked to make regular payments for the rest of your life.. Please don't make too much attention to Kayse, he's an angry man..

    Osman Qaal

  7. Moliye says:

    No Somali wants to dismantle Somaliland other than the sick tribal entity of buuqland:

    Waxaa Maanta shir deg-deg ah oo ay qaban-qaabiyeen Jaaliyada Reer Puntland ee Norway, gaar ahaan Magaalada Oslo lagu qabtey Oslo, kaasoo looga hadlay arimo ku saabsan Shirka London uga socda Dowlada KMG iyo Maamulka Somaliland.

    Shirka jaaliyadda Puntland ayaa lagu gorfeeyey arimo ay ka mid yihiin talaabooyinka laga qaadan karo hadii shirka ay kasoo baxaan qodobo ama go’aamo ka dhan ah Ummada Somaliyeed iyo wadajirkeeda.

    • ali says:

      This is rabush & lies.if Puntland wants to dismantle They could done it long time or could go Their own way cuz They have enough population stability. it’s other way around s/land region tried to gp separately it did not work.

  8. Raage says:

    Once again, the lure of recognition is forcing Somaliland politicians into an untenable situation. The political leaders of Somaliland need to channel their energies into making Somaliland an economically viable place for it's people, and to build the armed forces in order to defend itself…..we don't need recognition, hand-outs by the world bank, IMF or any other entity. My hope is that the politicians will wake up and realize that we abosuletly and unequivocally do not need to Somalia.

  9. Kid Carlito says:

    Somaliland, this is bigger than any one of us, it is our country, We will defend its Sovereignty to the last man, woman or child.

    Somaliland, there is no way we are changing course. This conversation is coming 20 years too late had it been 1991-1994 I would understand people bring this reuniting concept back, however, we have come much too far, lost much too lives and strived much too hard to give up our dream!

    Good article!!

  10. hamze says:

    sool and bari sanag and cayn and awdal region already wanted to be pro somalia but cow muse n hj can separet if thy want leave khatmuo state and awdal state m warsans ppl alone

  11. Gaade says:

    My view of this is that the talks are necessary in order to pave the way for a referendum under the UN observers. Regardless of Somalia's stance, if the talks do not go anywhere and each side insist on their respected positions the world will be forced to call a referendum as they will not risk another prolong war that will destabilise the entire region.

  12. Jamaal Kadiye says:

    Do Somalilanders really want a small, poor east African country that is internationally irrelevant? Maybe they see the mess that Somalia is in and don't want to be in that mess but believe me it will not take that long for Somalia to retain its glory once a government takes root. It is just a mater of time.

    • Jamal says:

      That is a daylight Dreamining in any way what richness are you infact youre rich of illiteracy and hooliganism and up to now youre still an interim Govt and you had five hundred tribal members of Parliament and you did not used them to bring stability in youre failed country Somalia. Dear brother Jamaal Kadiye what you have written here has no meaning to Democratic Republic of Somaliland. Unless if you need some expatriate of Somalilanders to come and teach you how to make a Good Gorveness and Multi partism and how Democracy works just because you are my Brotherly Country Somalia.

  13. Allemagan says:

    Were are from Somaliland and we don't want to do anything with Somalia – I would like to know what was in the minds of these European mediators as they listened to the bright Doctor Omer. The mediators must have been scratching their heads to figure out which Somali is which Somali and where does the difference between these people lie! Maybe the secessionist's argument would make more sense if they chose "Garadagland" as a name for clarity sake.

    There must be a way we could agree as Somalis to at least stop the toxic waste dumping in our long shoreline; Short of that, the whole Somali peninsula may in the near future become an environmental disaster zone that is inhabitable for a man or beast.

    • Allemagan says:

      uninhabitable for a man or a beast that is ..

  14. khaatumo citizen says:

    unlike Mr ictiraaf, khaatumo state is real and has nothing to with TFG or puntland.. matter of fact puntland agaisnt khaatumo as much as you guys do… we also know somaliland airnt trying to reach what it used to be known former british colonial borders if so they have stayed tukoraq the other day.. traitors like ina cambashe, hasade, cadami etc are on the run and already built thier house in hargisa and burco.

    • Jamal says:

      You khaatumo citizen you have lost your identity as who you are. Please come to your sense and do not become too cheap to other people and start grying like a child who has lost his parents. Dear brother you have gone to the people who have lost thier identity and you are one of them? what a pity please do not to miss lead your people to a plce of no where. frankly you will gain nothing more than a falier.

  15. Dhugtame says:

    To Kediye,
    "Do Somalilanders really want a small,poor east African country that is internationally irrelevant?" Exactly, we want our poor east African country back from the Haynes to the South and we will show you that Somaliland was was not, is not and will not be internationally irrelevant. Somalia is internationally irrelevant and will remain as such for the coming decades.

    To Allemegan:

    The international community can clearly tell who is who and from where, but the problem is with you, the deluded people from Somalia that can not read the big writings on the wall. What does getting the support of legal , security and economic experts for each party in the next Somaliland-Somalia dialogue sound to you? THAT MEANS; SOMALILAND SOVEREIGNTY IS COMING SOON! if you do not believe me talk to the Somalia attendees in the Kent conference.
    Good bye neighbor!

    • kent says:

      will not happen That not need to waste your build your region.

      • kent says:

        correction, no need to waste your time better do something constructive such build your region as a semi-autonomous state.


You must be logged in to post a comment.

More in Opinions (350 of 839 articles)
Aw-Libaax023-300x174 and daughter