Somaliland

Somaliland: Stop Deporting Ethiopian Refugees

September 4, 2012   ·   58 Comments

Ethiopianrefugees_118165217_540x405

 

Dozens, Including Women, Children, Forced Back to Ethiopia

(Nairobi, September 4, 2012) – The Somaliland authorities should immediately stop deporting Ethiopian refugees and asylum seekers to Ethiopia, Human Rights Watch said today. On August 31, 2012, dozens of Ethiopians, mostly women and children, were forcibly returned to Ethiopia in violation of international legal prohibitions against sending people to places where they might face persecution or threats to their lives.

The Somaliland authorities deported Ethiopians arrested after police raids on August 30 and 31 on an informal settlement known as the Social Welfare Centre in Somaliland’s main city, Hargeisa, where several hundred asylum seekers and migrants from Ethiopia have lived for almost a year. The exact number and immigration status of those returned is unclear, but a witness estimated seeing around 100 people sent across the border. In late December 2011, Somaliland attempted to forcibly return 20 Ethiopian refugees and asylum seekers and tried to close down the Social Welfare Centre.

“Rounding up and deporting asylum seekers is not the way to treat vulnerable people seeking Somaliland’s protection,” said Leslie Lefkow, deputy Africa director at Human Rights Watch. “Somaliland authorities should instead ensure that Ethiopian asylum seekers are registered and given the protection and assistance to which they are entitled.”

Human Rights Watch said deporting registered refugees and asylum seekers constitutes refoulement, the unlawful return of anyone to persecution or to a place where their life or freedom is threatened. International law prohibits the deportation of anyone seeking asylum before they have received a fair determination of their claim.

Local sources told Human Rights Watch that on the morning of August 30 the owner of land surrounding the Social Welfare Centre told the Ethiopians living there to leave. When they refused, fighting broke out and police arrived. According to witnesses, police fired live ammunition during the ensuing struggle and wounded at least six Ethiopians, including one who was shot in the arm and the leg. The sources also said Ethiopians at the centre may have injured four police officers.

The police then arrested 56 of the Ethiopians, including the majority of those injured, and took them to different detention facilities in Hargeisa. 25 registered refugees and two asylum seekers were detained at the Central Police Station. One of those refugees told Human Rights Watch that six injured refugees had not received medical assistance for three days before they were released.

According to witnesses, police returned to the centre during the morning and early afternoon of August 31 and loaded dozens of people – mainly women and children – onto several trucks and drove them to the border town of Wajale. The same afternoon, the police drove 28 men they had detained on August 30 in Hargeisa to Wajale. The first two trucks, one carrying the men and another carrying primarily women and children, immediately crossed into Ethiopia and dropped the individuals off on Ethiopian territory.

According to the United Nations refugee agency, on the evening of August 31 staff members identified 72 refugees among the group still at Wajale, as well as one woman who had been driven across to the Ethiopian side of the border. The refugee agency returned them to Hargeisa.

However, Somaliland authorities prevented the UN refugee agency from assisting an unknown number of other individuals in Wajale, including registered asylum seekers, and the individuals who had already been brought across the border to Ethiopia. As of September 4, the location of the other Ethiopians returned to their country was unknown, Human Rights Watch said. An unconfirmed report said that 32 men were detained at the Ethiopian border post until the afternoon of September 1, when Ethiopian authorities transferred them to an unknown location.

“The Somaliland authorities should allow the UN refugee agency prompt access to Ethiopians facing deportation to give them a chance to seek asylum,” Lefkow said. “The ongoing deadlock in the asylum process in Somaliland is not an excuse for any abuses.”

Background
Since October 2011, hundreds of refugees and asylum seekers from Ethiopia – as well as migrants who have been unable to claim asylum since the Somaliland authorities suspended registration in 2008 – have lived in the Social Welfare Centre, which was leased by the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR).

Since the lease ended in late December 2011, the centre’s owner has pressed the authorities to forcibly evict those living there. In March 2012, the authorities destroyed part of a makeshift camp set up on the edge of the centre, saying it was part of a wider urban “clean-up exercise.”

Somaliland ended all registration of asylum seekers in October 2008 following a series of suicide bombings in Hargeisa. UNHCR estimates that there are at least 20,000 undocumented foreigners in Somaliland, including unknown numbers of Ethiopians and others who want to claim asylum but cannot do so because they cannot register. Since March 2012, UNHCR and the minister of interior have been re-registering asylum seekers who registered before October 2008, although it appears asylum claims have not all been reviewed. UNHCR says registration of all non-registered migrants is scheduled to resume in September 2012.

Large numbers flee Ethiopia to escape persecution every year. Refugees who are returned by force have frequently been detained by the authorities. Torture is common in Ethiopia’s prisons.

For more Human Rights Watch reporting on Somalia, please visit:
http://www.hrw.org/africa/somalia

For more information please contact:
In Amsterdam, Leslie Lefkow (English): +31-6-21-59-73-56 (mobile); or lefkowl@hrw.org
In Nairobi, Laetitia Bader (English, French): +254-700-241-854 (mobile); or baderl@hrw.org
In Geneva, Gerry Simpson (English, French, German, Italian, Spanish): +33-6-93-74-56-07; + 41-79-219-95-68; or simpsog@hrw.org
In London, Ben Rawlence (English, Swahili): +44-798-481-6013 (mobile); or rawlenb@hrw.org

By

Tags: , , ,


Readers Comments (58)

  1. isaaqunionist says:

    This is so sickening to me. This is probably another way the Somaliland Government is sucking up to the Ethiopian Government. ;(

    • kaboon says:

      fake name

      • Waddaniyad says:

        Fake name, intruder, infiltrator

    • mohamed cheers says:

      I smell the smell of Kayse film hindi lol.
      Cheers.

  2. kaboon says:

    wallah this is sooo disgusting. why are we deporting Ethiopian refugees, we shouldn't deport refugees from anywhere. I hope those so-called sheikhs speak out against is un-islamic act from our misguided government. No one is asking for these people to be deported and we somalilanders DON'T WANT THESE INNOCENT PEOPLE TO BE MADE INTO SCAPEGOATS.

  3. khaatumo citizen says:

    if they are muslims we should let them stay,

    • kaboon says:

      Ethiopia holds millions of Muslim Somali refugees stop discriminating. like i said time and time again there seems to be a fake Islam seeping the central regions of Somalia.

      • khaatumo citizen says:

        I know it doesn't matter whether they are Muslim or non-muslims, I respect all regions. but adiga habashi miyaad tahayna waan kaayabay intaa Habashi uun baad no faanin..

        • Somalilander says:

          Their should a propose that they are coming! Somali Asylum seekers in Suadi Arabia you know how Arabs are treating with them my friend yet they are Muslims………

          • Truth says:

            @Somalilander….You don't make sense, in fact you you are a retard if you are justifying this by mentioning what Saudi Arabia ( a monarchy state) does to fellow Muslims. You should learn from someone's mistake, not follow in to their footstep!

             
  4. isaaqunionist says:

    what do you mean fake name kaboon?

  5. sahra says:

    biyo kaabadan iyo dad kaabadan waaku qaadaan let them stay it will be their land tomorrow

  6. amal says:

    Looks like our government is constantly making the wrong moves. If these are just women and children and weak people who fled from their country then we should just let them stay. Refugees deserve shelter and safety.

    • Dhuguse says:

      We can understand the position of Somaliland. Now, in Hargeisa almost 20% of the population are Ethiopian oromos and they are still keep coming day and night. The question is, how much more Ethiopians can Somaliland accommodate while its citizens are semi refugees in their own country and everything is in scarcity. We also know those Oromos are not genuine refugees but economic exodus from our mighty neighbour. I guess, Ethiopia doesn't want to make cooperation of the this problem with Somaliland Government.

      • amal says:

        Dhuguse,
        20%? that's a lot. I just feel sorry for weak people that need help by allowing UN agency to assist them especially women and children. But that doesn't mean they can just flock into our country like that for economic reasons but maybe we can restrict the refugee inflow instead of kicking the already settled ones out. Ethiopia doesn't want to cooperate anything with us because they just want us to be a bloody door mat for them.

  7. common sense says:

    Welcom to somali regoin of ethiopa #2. This what we should call somaliland region. The salanyio govt was asked by ethiopia to hand over theses ppl who r families of rebels of the oromo liberation melitia or they think they r. And then silanyio govt is deporting kids and womens so they can be tutured back in ethipia. And guss what the ethiopian govts do in return they arm a miltia in buhhudle and provide army escort to the militia leader to go inside sl and kill hundereds of somali isaaqs in the ogaden region. I,m telling u this sh## by silanyio has to stop. This guy is harming isaqs more than any other tribe and we isaaq will pay the price.

  8. whineforit says:

    Hold on. If Somaliland does something this way. They protest. If they choose to go the other they protest. I thought Somaliland was not a government. So why ask them or expect anything from them.

    Somaliland should not involve itself with either the Human rights or Ethiopia problems. It should remain neutral since UNPOS are aware Somaliland itself maybe being used to cause insecurity for countries that do not recognise it nor support it to the level it requires encase conflict occurs.

    Either way we are wrong.

  9. whineforit says:

    Besides we can as of now send them on to 'Somalia' if they wish.

  10. sahra says:

    to be fair my neighbor was telling me there is a lot of Oromo in bosaso there is nasty agenda going on

  11. mohamed cheers says:

    Wait a minute..refugees from Ethiopia? Why Refugees from Ethiopia in the first place,
    what's their problem and why are they refugees? If they are Ogaaden or Oromo, I think
    the Somaliland Govt should take this matter to the Addis Ababa Central Govt to find ways
    to settle these crisis. The UN high commissioner and UNHCR should also help.
    A special high profile committee should be set-up from the Somaliland side to supervise
    and co-ordinate these vital issues. Ethiopia is not a poor country so why Refugees? Where' are
    all the nillions of aids from the IC to Ethiopia going?, when poverty striken Ethiopian refugees are flooding the unrecognized Somaliland by the thousands??? The Refugees from Somalia
    should also be dealt with in some other policy by the Somaliland Govt.
    Cheers.

  12. Guest says:

    This is why people flee Ethiopia including Oromo http://www.hrw.org/news/2012/08/28/ethiopia-army-

  13. Seeking truth says:

    Ethiopia participates in attacks on civilians in Somalia. http://www.hrw.org/news/2012/03/28/somalia-pro-go

  14. abdisalan says:

    put them in camps in a remote village let the ngos feed them and besides do not allow them in the cities they will overtake the locals . it is good , refugees from ethiopia in somalia but they should live in squalid camps.call the world over to see this desparate meles children dying of hunger just like they were doing to somalis . now it is their turn .

  15. Kayse Libaaxa Badaa says:

    I like how "Somalilanders" cry over few deported Ethiopian spies but as soon as they hear internally displaced people from different regions of this troubled Somali Republic; they take out their shot guns and celebrate their sufferings.

    For a minute stop, think and ask yourself, why your so upset over this incident but you celebrate if you hear about Somalis being displaced?

  16. Sheik Farhan says:

    Xoolo Somaliland don’t you that you have more than 100,000 somalilandis are living in Ethiopia Addis Ababa hahahaha….. Are they refugees??????????? Selfish Somaliland

  17. Sheik Farhan says:

    Xoolo Somaliland don’t you know that you have more than 100,000 somalilandis are living in Ethiopia Addis Ababa hahahaha….. Are they refugees??????????? Selfish Somaliland

  18. ComeAgain says:

    Lets stop having this irrational fear of Ethiopians, last I remember it was fellow Somalis who were killing Landers not Ethiopians! Was it Ethiopia who was bombing Hargeisa, Burcao etc? Was it Christian Ethiopians killing Somali Muslims or was it Somali Muslims killing Landers?

    I am living in a country full of people with different beliefs that choose to live in peace together, and I think Somaliland should be the same, we should welcome the needy but also make sure that no criminals come into our borders.

    Lets not forget it was Ethiopia that welcomed our people when other Somalis and so called Muslims were only too willing to wipe us off the map!

    Commen sense is not the monopoly of one religion, ethinicity, or nation. Maybe Somaliland will one day be the America of Africa!

    • PuntlandGeezer says:

      ethiopian lover, you ought to be ashamed of yourself.

    • Khadar says:

      Come again COME AGAiN, Excuse me Brother wasn't it Darods were the ones that attacked Somaliland during the civil war in the late 1980's and early 1990's. Not Somalis Muslims.
      Ethiopians are going take over the over the country if they are not deported as soon as possible. Ethiopians are beggers and criminals in the streets of Hargeisa. They should be thrown out of the country because they are useless the government does not benefit from them it is them that is trying benefit from the country and all they do is sit on their butts and complain. They are burden to Somaliland because they don't do anything.
      What about the southners in Somaliland they are benefit to Somaliland. They have businesses in Somaliland since they left the south 5 years during the Ethiopian invasion and Abdullahi Yusuf invasion.

      • Khadar says:

        Southners have businesses in Hargeisa since 2007 or before explain to me why there are more business owned by southners in Hargeisa and none by ethiopians and don't put ethiopian airlines it is state owned airline. Southners are our brothers and sisters not ethiopians.

    • Truth says:

      @ComeAgain….. Are you uneducated about the word ''Somali'' or are you just a retard. Somali is ethnicity, therefore the people Somaliland, Ogadens, NFD, Djibouti and Somalia are all Somalis!! BY THE WAY, the word Somaliland means ''THE LAND OF THE SOMALI PEOPLE'', that's why the colonisers called the South and North ''Somaliland'' (Italian Somaliland & Britain Somaliland). I HOPE YOU INJECT THIS VALUABLE INFORMATION IN TO YOUR BRAIN. Cheers

      Now you may continue spitting out the pathetic grudges you have for the people of Somalia.

    • Mohamd says:

      Zoomalis are undeserving people who are nothing but leeches. It is shame such ugly people were Somalisised instead of leaving them with their Bantus or Slaves of Bander Qasim origin.

      • Khadar says:

        What's the hostility with the somali people Mahamed, I love all somali people man. They are not zoomalis what make us zomalilanders.

        • Khadar says:

          We are not zomalilanders, And there is no zomalis.

        • tr says:

          mohamed+khadar AL-XAWAYANAAD.There is no such Think call”lander”only dilusionsit world exists This word.

          • Guled says:

            Well for your big fat information Somaliland is not illusional it is real and the word lander is not illusional. So you bo yeah sucker.

             
  19. Mohamd says:

    SL is nothing but a transit point for Ethiopian refugees. As long as they register themselves as refugees, they reserve the right to apply for resettlement programmes in Europe and USA. So this role of taking part in the new Africa slave/refugee trade is just plain wrong.

  20. PuntlandGeezer says:

    who give these muppets the rights to deport refugees from somalia? they hardly control any territory expect the small tribal village hargeisa. after we finish al shabaab these muppets are next, we gona clean hargeisa from traitors.

  21. amal says:

    can we not just recruit them into the army. They might as well be useful if they are flooding in

    • Truth says:

      LOOL Is staggering to me how you actually look down on those refugees (shaking my head). They came there for help and you want to use them? Wish you were in them shoes! Pleas kill yourself you are inhumane.

      • khaatumo citizen says:

        Truth waryaa don't talk to girl like that, what's wrong with somali men these days Akhas..

        Amal somaliland barely can afford to provide those Dibjiro duleedka Lascanod their daily basis forget about recruiting some Oromas lol

        • Truth says:

          Khaatumo citizen looooooooooool you are one sly guy!!

          • khaatumo citizen says:

            I'm not a guy, but serously though u shouldn't be insulting a girl like that.. ceeb.

             
          • Truth says:

            Khaatumo citizen.. Sorry for assuming that you were a guy. I didn't insult her honestly, the only bad thing I might have said is ''kill yourself''. Of course I didn't meant it literally, I was just showing her how inhumane her comment and thoughts were.

             
          • khaatumo citizen says:

            okay then..

            we actually had 2 habashi maids back home I don't want them to be deported they are very helpful lool

             
          • Truth says:

            LOL What is wrong with our womans now day? Damnn you are the same as amal.. Seems like men have bigger heart than Somali women

             
        • amal says:

          looooooooooool
          khaatumo citizen walalo thanks lol Truth is an emotional Ethiopian kkkk don't worry he too can be our servant lol just kidding

          What's wrong recruiting Ethiopians if we can, they can't just beg around the streets of Somali cities if they want to settle. What help can a poor nation give. The skillful ones can do whatever else they can that both helps them and contributes to our nation building.

      • amal says:

        Truth I didn't mean to offend you but if you are Ethiopian and you want to stay then maybe you can clean our toilets lol

        • Truth says:

          amal LOOL, for the record ''I am Somali'' sister :), therefore I can't be a servant. Sorry

          • khaatumo citizen says:

            looooooooool
            amal, we officially hired Truth, his shift starts next week lool
            the reason we can't recruit them is because of the poor economics we rely on ports airports and diaspora

            Truth just kidding you mate. :)

             
  22. Truth says:

    @ComeAgain….. Are you uneducated about the word ''Somali'' or are you just a retard. Somali is ethnicity, therefore the people Somaliland, Ogadens, NFD, Djibouti and Somalia are all Somalis!! BY THE WAY, the word Somaliland means ''THE LAND OF THE SOMALI PEOPLE'', that's why the colonisers called the South and North ''Somaliland'' (Italian Somaliland & Britain Somaliland). I HOPE YOU INJECT THIS VALUABLE INFORMATION IN TO YOUR BRAIN. Cheers

    Now you may continue spitting out the pathetic grudges you have for your fellow Somali people of Somalia.

    • jama says:

      Truth,teach few lessons This crazzy creatures such as comeagain.

      • Khadar says:

        Yo Jama the cook what's up my nigga.

  23. Jabuutawi says:

    And on a different note, I kind of miss Gobaad. What happened to that gal? Yes, she was, still is?, clannish to the core but I miss….KA NAHOW NAFTA WA….Booyah!

  24. Jabuutawi says:

    Oh yeah, back to the subject matter. Oromos need to go back and reclaim their land from Amhara and Tigray…I am just saying.

    • naasir says:

      jabuutawi,your right, it’s The bl@@dy oromos claim back Their land from Amhara and Tigray injireey.maybe Amharas/Tigray They have bigger Agenda which is to bush all These oromos into nothern somalia.

      • naasir says:

        correct,it’s time bl@@dy oromos.

  25. ibrahimmoamin says:

    subhanALLAH ! What happen to sumaliland? Do u know what happen to those people ?


You must be logged in to post a comment.

More in Somaliland (543 of 1561 articles)
Somali passports