Opinions

Somaliland: Learned helplessness

July 7, 2012   ·   37 Comments

Berbera International Airport, Berbera, Somaliland

Berbera International Airport, Berbera, Somaliland (Yusuf Dahir).

SAED A. ELMI

When one believes that one’s own action has no affect what so ever, on changing one’s destiny and therefore, there is no point of even trying to escape from the unpleasant situation, then one is said to be in a state of learned helplessness. In this state, one believes that events and experiences are uncontrollable; therefore, there is no relationship between action and outcome. The concept of learned helplessness is defined as the belief that one’s actions have no influence on the outcome of an event.

When a nation becomes helpless and does nothing to improve the lives of its citizens, its infrastructure, its healthcare system, its education system and its governance, then it is fair to say that it is in a state of learned helplessness. A nation that is helpless and is doing nothing proactive to change its destiny is not independent. History tells us that those who do not learn from their mistakes are destine to repeat those mistakes. If Somaliland wants to be recognized and respected by other nations, then it is paramount that the nation heals its collective psychic first.

Somaliland had the unfortunate history of first been colonized and ruled by the British and second by the brutal dictator Siyaad Bare, who before his iron grip slipped from power, authorized the destruction of every institution in the northern part of the country and the systematic killing of its inhabitants mainly from the Isaaq clan. Both of these events (been colonized for so many years and having a psychopath ruler) are the causes of the Somaliland illness.

Somaliland broke away from the iron grip of Siyad Bare in 1991 and since then has enjoyed a relatively peace and prosperity, but the country has no safety net. The idea of getting recognized and becoming a member of the United Nations is appealing, but we need to be realistic. For the sake of the argument, let us say we get recognition today, then what? If we do not have the safety net, strong institutions such as a defense department that can protect the nation, a healthcare department that is capable of providing the necessary basic health care that other nations take for granted, than recognition is meaningless.

My point here is that we are dependent on charity from others; our leaders, instead of encouraging us to become independent, our leaders are going around looking for charity. We cannot achieve independence unless we first become psychologically independent. We have been thought indirectly that we cannot achieve anything without the help of others; we cannot have fair elections without international observers, in other words we are told indirectly that we are inferior to others and that we need to let others make decisions for us. It is not the lack of resources that is holding us back, what is holding us back is that we gave up a long time ago; it is the lack of motivation that is holding us back. Because we failed so many times we are afraid that we will fail again and as a result of this, we learned helplessness. We want others to build hospitals for us, we want others to come and find oil for us, we want others to come and feed us, we became over relying on foreign aid. When are we ever going to do anything for our country without asking for help from others who do not have our best interest at their hearts?

The key to overcome this helplessness is motivation. We need to motivate our leaders, and remind them that we survived for twenty one years without recognition and without the help of others. We need to stop worrying about recognition and we need to start building institutions that are capable of providing our citizens basic needs like healthcare, security, education, clean water and sewer system . Instead of begging others to recognize us, we need to hold our leaders accountable and demand for better institutions, institutions that are not just names, but are effective in eliminating poverty, providing high quality healthcare, decreasing the high mortality rate and create a sustainable economy.

We need to stop chasing after international donors and start thinking of how we can build the safety net institutions that will help get us on the way to recovery. We cannot change the past but we can influence the future.

Our success depends on the choices we make today. We can continue looking for charity or we can get up and work hard to build a nation that can provide its citizens a decent life. The world will recognize us when we show the world that we can rebuild our country, we can live peacefully with our neighbors and we can manage our resources independently. This is not hard to do, but first we as a nation need to stop looking for free lunch, because there is no free lunch in this world, we either work hard for the things we want or we keep begging for the things we want, the choice is ours.

By Saeed A Elmi

Healthcare Administration.

Psychiatric Technician.

By

Tags: , , , ,


Readers Comments (37)

  1. Kayse says:

    When a "nation" is driven by hate, memories of war and scars—-it always ends up where Somaliland is. No vision, no policies, no ideas—-just we got killed and we will lock ourselves inside —- albabkaa ii xiidh aan ooye. 21 years of tears and isolation. The infrastructure Siad Bare left behind is crumpling away and soon people will realise this "government" does nothing but affix the works of Siad Bare—like the kids standing in Somaliland's main roads with the shuffles…filing those holes with sands.

    It has failed miserably and the biggest failure is Silaanyo, before north Somalis had nothing but lived in peace now there is no peace, no development, no healing, no recognition, no capital…don't know what keeps them going.

  2. khaatumo citizen says:

    TRUE it's time somalilanders stop worrying about never coming recognition and feed the starving people in Saraar, Sahil, Zailac and some parts of sanaag.. nice photo thoe last time i been to Berbera it was compeletly different well done reer berbera..

  3. Mahmoud says:

    I dis agree Mr Kayse Somaliland has achieved all the points you have mentioned i.e peace, held free and fair democratic elections spearheaded by Riyale and AMM sirayo I also liked to clarify to you that Somaliland infrastructure was bult when somaliland was a British protectorate . I know lots of our new generation are all educated now then ever before and has the vision, leadership, and tommorow is bright I can see when we produce our natural resources the world will run to us like birds let make dua inshallah god willing it will be sooner rather then later no more dulinimo

  4. Abdikhadar says:

    Kayse seriously you need help, and if anybody is driven by hate it is you.. What I don't get is it's obviously you hate siilanyo for tribal reasons, but would you hate somaliland if it had HY president..

    • Zac says:

      Good point

    • Ali says:

      Keyse has nothing to do with HY he is an Ogaadeen refugee.

  5. misslovely says:

    do you learn all this hate from your moster ethopia please stay with in your border and stay away from somaliland we don't need hateful ethopian in somaliland i know you are not a lander so s/land is not your concern

    • Saeed Elmi says:

      Obviously you are confused and ignorant. Your comments have nothing to do with my article. If you can't read the English language please learn first before you comment on article that are beyond your comprehension. For your information I was born in Hargaisa and I do not hide behind a funky name. When I write article or post comments I use my real name, because that is what real writers do. My article has nothing to do with hate and it has every thing to do with psychology, my be that is why you are not understanding it. It is beyond your comprehension.

      Lastly by posting comments like the one you posted, you only letting us know how ignorant you are.

      • Kayse says:

        Dear Saeed,

        First of all congratulations on the article because you did remarkable job in addressing key issues. Most "Somalilanders" have an issue saying "we have a problem that needs fixing"— for them everything is perfect and Utopia.

        In your article you admitted and thats how you fix a problem by saying there is one. The reason problems are piling up in Somaliland is because we have people who are just cheerleaders, if you kick them in the butt with a Somaliland boot they will say "Alla wa mujahiidki SNM lugtiisi"…

        If you tell them there is gold near Las Anood on the other side, they will say to you—you crazy faqash….don't mention there is gold in walaweyn, there is nothing there….

        We gotto break them down and show them the reality. They are blinded by hate. Last time many in Burao did not even know what June 26 was, some of them even said "Wa maalinti Nabbigu dhashtay mala (SCW)"…the videos are on youtube.

        You can't imagine the level of ignorance.

        Don't worry about missLovely, she is addressing me. She is calling me Ethiopia because I'm also from Hawd where her milk and meat comes from….giving Somali territory to her usual masters who refused to recognize her little enclave.

  6. saeed Elmi says:

    Read the article please, and try to understand it. because by reading your comment I can see you are having a hard time understanding what is written, I wonder why.

  7. Aydid Somalilander says:

    Talk and writing an article is cheap. Both you Kasye" the psycho" and the author of this article Mr. Elmi,you can both say or write anything you want but the question that the people of Somaliland want to ask you is,except for criticism and pretending to know all, what have you ever done for Somaliland and it's people that you can point to today?

    The answer is for sure absolutely nothing. So please, shut up and follow the mass.

    • saeed Elmi says:

      Understanding your psychological make up will help you solve problems. I am not sure why you are so upset, you probably did not understand what learned helplessness means. Let me help you out, learned helplessness is the reason you are upset, because you feel inferior to others and therefore instead of commenting about the article which was probably beyond your education level, you attack and insult people, that is your defense mechanism. Now that I fought fire with fire which is not my character. let me tell you what an educated person would do when he reads and article, he would analyse the content, understand it and then give constrictive feed back . I don't know who you are nor do I care to know such a person like you but you are not a Somali lander. Oh by the way I was not criticizing Somali-land I am encouraging my people to achieve more. See if you analyse the content of the article then you will see my point.

  8. misslovely says:

    @SAEED ELMI_
    WALAAL COME DOWN I AM NOT TALKING TO YOU WALAAHI I AM TALKING TO MR KAYSE WHOSE IS FULL OF HATE HE IS ALWAYS BAD MOUTHING ABOUT MY TRIBE THATS WHY I AM ANGRY WITH HIM SORRY ABOUT THE BAD LANGUAGE I SPEAK GERMAN AND CHINES

    • Somaliaqueen says:

      It takes one to know one, what goes around comes around

  9. misslovely says:

    BY THE WAY I UNDERSTOOD EVERY LINE OF YOUR ARTICAL THANKS

  10. troll hunter says:

    kayse kayse, no life no wife, obsessed with being noticed by Somalilanders. Keep on hating, while we move on……

  11. Danaakilinho says:

    I really don't understand this guy kayse nacas,I sometimes think do you feel sorry for him or laugh at him. Kayse nacas you are a southerner who is always talking through your arse. Why are you always obsessed with every article that has something to do with Somaliland.

    You just say anything to get noticed, you can hate as much as you like, but the only way is up for Somaliland.

  12. Dhugtame says:

    I think Mr. Elmi has three problem that he needs to recognize before he bad mouths others. First, I think the guy is too sensitive and that is a very bad professional character, he needs to develop a thicker skin or stop posting articles. In other words, if he doesn't like the heat he should stay out of the kitchen.

    Secondly, He is full of himself and overestimates his talents and professional qualifications. I do not know Misslovely personally but I have learned from her comments in SLpress that she is very articulate and highly educated person. Therefore, it is quite unfortunate from Mr. Elmi's part to give the demeaning response to her, instead of responding with reason and patience.

    Thirdly, he fails to understand that Somaliland was under occupation before 1991 and had zero infra structure. Let alone basic services, there was no single building standing in its major cities, when it was liberated from Siyaad Barre. Somaliland was in worst shape than post Hitler Europe. The Marshall plan was what made Europe to stand on its feet and without it the glimmer that you see today wouldn't have been possible with out USA help. Somaliland had no Marshall plan, but was put under deadly sanctions for the most years of its independence. Despite all the sanctions, the Somaliland people have miraculously risen out of the ashes and have achieved what they have achieved to date and this is just the begging and you haven't seen the end yet.

    It is unreasonable and easy to write a piece of opinion from your comfortable home in North America, were you are guaranteed a safety net by your host country to which you had almost no contribution and criticize those who live and breath the fruits of their hard work and perseverance day and night.

    Recognition is very important to Somaliland and this is why, any other country in the world would have ceased to exist if it was in the same situation as Somaliland. Just look around and see what is happening in countries like Spain and Greece, countries with more resources and friends than Somaliland. If you do not have a strong economy you will not be able to do anything. And foreign investment is the secret word for growth and if not recognized you will have zero investment and economic growth. But Somaliland has defied the rules and is doing much better than expected.

    Please learn to give credit to your hard working people and get off you ego. To Keyse I say nothing, because he deserves no response.

    • saeed Elmi says:

      Again read the article and give your comments about the article. May be look up the concept of learned helplessness you may learn something about your self. You see, your comments have nothing to do with the article what so ever.

      • Dhugtame says:

        Elmi

        I regret that I have commented earlier. I was just trying to help, but it seems that you are always in defensive and offending mood and no amount of good advice will help.

        Sorry carry on.

        • saeed Elmi says:

          I am not even sure if you even understand your own comments. What good advice are you giving me? Read your earlier comments and then read my article again and you will see that your comments were in congruent. You attacked me and insulted me for trying to explain the concept of learned helplessness . The article I wrote is about a psychological concept and in fact every Somali person should understand the concept of learned helplessness. Understanding this concept Somalians can solve their problems.

  13. Omer says:

    @ Elmi

    By the way, I'm a medical professional, I have practiced medicine in North America, Europe and the middle east and I have not heard of a psychiatric technician before, is it an other word for a psychiatric nurse? I know that there are laboratory technicians or imaging technicians, but no idea what Psychiatric technician is and I have not seen a psychiatrist dealing with any equipment other than their pens and papers. Please enlighten me.

    • saeed Elmi says:

      Omer.
      Here is the definition of psychiatric technician. It is a nursing profession that specializes in Mental illnesses and developmental disabilities.

      The Psychiatric Technician is a nursing category parallel to Licensed Vocational Nurse (California's term for Licensed Practical Nurse). Psychiatric Technician skills focus on mental illnesses and developmental disabilities, while Licensed Vocational Nurses have an emphasis on maternity and pediatric nursing.
      As multi-talented mental health professionals with a broad range of skills and expertise, Psychiatric Technicians are key players in the many and varied aspects of California's system of treating those with mental illness or developmental disabilities. It is a profession that attracts those who truly want to help improve the quality of life for some of the most vulnerable individuals in today's society.

      This information is direcly from California Association of Psychiatric Technicians http://www.psych-health.com/

      • Omer says:

        Thanks for the clarifications. Does that mean that you are a practical nurse and not a registered nurse?

        • saeed Elmi says:

          Omar. I am not a practical nurse nor a Registered nurse. I am a Licensed Psychiatric technician. The difference here is that psychiatric technicians have more training in psych were the RN and the LVNs focus mainly on med search. just as the name suggests, psych Techs treat those with mental illnesses or developmental disabilities.

          Where do you practice medicine?

          • Omer says:

            New York State. I know what nurses do, because I deal with them in my daily practice, but Psychiatric Technician was new to me.

            Anyway, I exactly know what you mean. FYI RNs do not only do Maternity and Pediatrics. You have Psychiatric, medical, Surgical, Public Health, Nurse practitioners and many other sub-specialties and interests. Good luck!

             
          • saeed Elmi says:

            I am assuming you are not a Psychiatrist but a Medical Doctor. New your also has psychiatric technicians mainly in their State Hospitals. New York State is one of four States that have Licence psychiatric technicians. Psychiatric technicians work only in Psychiatric Facilities and mostly work in State Hospitals. It is a growing professional and it is replacing psychiatric nurses.
            Thank You.

             
          • Ahmed says:

            Saeed Elmi,

            I'm a medical student currently rotating in Psychiatric dept in my university hospital. I find your answer to the doctor very strange indeed. I think you believe that Medical doctors do not know what they talking about.
            Every Medical doctor does a psychiatry rotation in their medical school training and psychiatry is part of the six subjects on USMLE exam. Telling a medical doctor that he doesn't understand the medical profession is shameful.
            Whether you like it or not psychiatric technician is what they call assistant nurse in the UK and a practical nurse in the USA. On your own admission you said psychiatric technicians are replacing the psychiatry nurse, that means to me there is no difference between the two.
            Your lack of understanding the basics of medical knowledge is just astonishing.

             
          • saeed Elmi says:

            Ahmed. First I don't understand what is strange about my answer to Mr Omar. I never said that Medical doctors do not know what they talk about nor did I tell him that he that he does not understand the medical profession. In my answers I explained to him what a psychiatric technician is and if you read carefully his reply " I know what nurses do, because I deal with them in my daily practice, but Psychiatric Technician was new to me." I was only pointing out that there are only four States in the united States that have psychiatric technician and that New York is one of these four States.
            I am not sure were you get your information from but practical nurse is not the same as psychiatric technician. Psychiatric technician holds a different license than practical nurse. I am not familiar with UK nursing but do assistant nurses in UK administer medications, supervise nurses, became unit supervisors, nursing coordinators, program directors and Clinical administrators? In the united states this is what psychiatric technicians are qualify to do, they run departments.

             
          • saeed Elmi says:

            FYI. Nurse, Psychiatric technician, Practical, nurse are names that describe Nursing professions, these are not basic medical knowledge. I don't understand what makes you think that I lack basic medical knowledge when I was not even talking about Medical knowledge. I was talking about Nursing professionals. And as a Medical student you should know that Psychiatric Nurses are not the same as psychiatric technician, may be the word Psychiatric is confusing you. Also why are you wasting your time and getting so mad, psychiatric technician is just a nursing profession.

             
  14. Ahmed says:

    Mr. writer, this is the nature of S/L people: people who want to enjoy a decent life without doing a single stroke of work. Drug addicts who waste their time on useless social chats, rumor-mongering, and begging in disguise.

    The leaders you are talking about seek office to embezzle funds from public money. They are not motivated by the promotion of national interests or campaign promises. So, please stay calm. Help is on the way and the real nationalists will return to power whereas those corrupt S/L "officials" will be put behind bars or will be hanged one by one. I understand and appreciate your frustration and disappointment: after 21 long painful years, Somaliland failed to achieve nothing tangible at all fronts.

    • Dhugtame says:

      Here we go again, another Keyse rubbing himself on the back and calling himself another name.

    • amal says:

      Ahmed,
      You and your ilk have nothing but hate and jealousy for Somaliland. We have created what you couldn't for the past 21 years; a stable and model of governance that is rare in the horn of Africa without any foreign intervention unlike you where bantus have to tell you what to do. Don't waste your time on Africa's best kept secret.

    • saeed Elmi says:

      I am not disappointed at all, I am actually quite pleased with what Somali-land achieved, I am simply trying to motivate my people to achieve more. Somali-land achieved what the rest of Somalia could not do.
      I suggest you look at the rest of Somalia and pray for them that they come to their senses and stop killing one another.
      And please stop pretending, Somali-land is my country. Try to do something with you life instead of hating S/L.

  15. Kayse says:

    hahahahaha looks like anti-Silaanyo list is growing by the minute. Elmi, those that believe in the isolation project can't handle criticism nor suggestions nor any feedback. Their little project is Utopia and there is no single problem, no one is angry, people are immortal, no diseases, no leadership defaults, no energy problems, no differences, no hate and everyone is inloveeeeee like Romeo and Juliet….the country is lush and rare fruits grow on every roof forget the land.

    That's what they want to hear not the reality.

    I am going to start my full war on Silaanyo very soon and I'm going to need all intellectuals from Somaliland so we can rescue our region from the new Siad Bare and all his tribalism, corruptions…in UK we going to also file human right lawsuits just in case he flees back…

    This is not the days of SNM, now everything is information and IT…the world is one village.

    We going to turn every Somaliland media except his inlaw Morgan (Bashe/Somaliland.org).

    I have so many Somaliland wealthy groups and I am going to hire public relation groups to awash the internet with anti-Silaanyo campaigns and show everyone the true image of Somaliland and the tribalist true Silaanyo.

    I'm going to begin this within the next four months because I am waiting for people inside Somaliland to collect the data and leave before we drop the bomb.

    I have also groups in Addis Ababa and we going to lobby the Ethiopian government to block Silaanyo because he has al Shabaab within his cabinet—recently a group of al Shabaab crossed into Somaliland including a Portuguese man.

    He was arrested but the son of Somaliland Minister was freed and he is in Hargeisa planning to attack Ethiopian targets.

    We going to arm Khaatumo, Awdal State and new groups against him should we need to take him out by force and like Saddam give him the same medicine.

    Already Somaliland is shaky and very fragile, everyone is suspicious and no one trusts Silaanyo nor likes him.

    He no longer goes out. His blood pressure is out of control and he wants to hand over to Hirsi Gaab and other Dhiigshiil affiliates.

    One of the guys arrested in Hargeisa last week, was Dhiigshiil employee wiring money to al Shabaab…Silaanyo, Dhiigshiil and al Shabaab are all affiliated.

    • saeed Elmi says:

      I have one word for you. You are DELUSIONAL.

  16. MSN info says:

    My wife is a nurse and she love reading, this article will be a good article for her to read.


You must be logged in to post a comment.

More in Opinions (335 of 846 articles)
Somali Union Party - democracy in Somaliland