Published On: Mon, Jun 21st, 2010

Somalia tops ‘failed states index’

MOGADISHU (Somalilandpress) — Somalia tops the list of so-called failed states, based on factors including its economy, human rights record and security, a new survey says.

The Fund for Peace and Foreign Policy Magazine released their 2010 “Failed States Index”, on Monday, ranking 177 countries to determine those most at risk of failure.

The annual report uses 12 metrics including security threats, economic implosion, human rights violations and refugee flows.

Since the index was published for the first time in 2005, the top 10 slots have rotated among just 15 countries, and Foreign Policy said it seems that state failure “is a chronic condition”.

Africa has seven of the top 10 spots, and half of the 60 weakest states.

Somalia, which has held the worst position for three years in a row, has not had an effective government since 1991. It is wracked by bloody fighting between anti-government groups and the army in large parts of the country and pirates are operating off the coast.



FAILED STATE INDEX
The least and most stable countries in the world:

1. Somalia
2. Chad
3. Sudan
4. Zimbabwe
5. DR Congo

173. Ireland
174. Switzerland
175. Sweden
176. Finland
177. Norway

Also listed is Zimbabwe, which moved down two ratings from last year, to number four, after a power sharing agreement was reached between the party of Robert Mugabe, the president, and Morgan Tsvangirai, the opposition leader who was named prime minister.

Some increased stability

Asia is home to 30 per cent of the top 60 weakest states and the Middle East has just over 10 per cent.

Afghanistan and Iraq, both with tens of thousands of US-led deployed troops, come in places six and seven respectively.

Yemen, meanwhile, saw increased instability in the last year while Sri Lanka received a better ranking this year.

Cynthia Pegrigh, the director of Policy at Conciliation Resources in London, told Al Jazeera that the index provides very informative analyses.

“However, the problem with these kind of rankings, is that it draws attention to the top 10 failed states, as they are called,” she said.

“If you take the example of Yemen, for decades, it has not been on the top 10 on these lists and media interest.

“Now, because of last year’s event, everybody is looking at the situation in Yemen,” she said, referring to the failed Christmas Day bombing of a jet en route to Detroit, where the alleged culprit apparently had ties to al-Qaeda in Yemen.

“What we say is that you should look at the complexities of all these countries in the long-term, not only when a crisis arises.”

Three Nordic nations - Norway, Finland and Sweden – are ranked as the most stable countries.

Source: Al Jazeera | Tuesday – June 22, 2010

  • Mustafe

    All the more reason why Somaliland should change it’s name as Faysal Waraabe suggested before

More in Africa (860 of 1156 articles)