Opinions

SOMALIA-SOMALILAND: The cake first, then the slices

July 2, 2012   ·   13 Comments

President Sheikh Sharif leaves a hotel after meeting with Somaliland president in Dubai, 28 of June 2012

BY BASHIR GOTH

It was a day like any other. A hot and bright summer day in the Washington D.C metropolitan area as we sat, a group of middle aged Somali men, in a good Afghani restaurant in Virginia at the invitation of a prominent Somalilander. We chatted like all Somalis do while we were waiting for the lunch to be served. We were five from Somaliland, and two from Southern Somalia. We exchanged hilarious anecdotes and humorous jokes on all issues. There was no sacrosanct topic in our jokes that covered culture, clans, economy and society.

But like all Somali conversations, we soon embarked on our most favorable topic; politics. Politics is the Somalis best past time conversation. Everything else acts as an appetizer for the hot plate of politics. No sooner do a group of Somalis sit together; they end up having animated discussions about politics no matter how and where their conversation begins.

So after the starter jokes, we turned to real politics, beginning with the recent talks of Somalia-Somaliland; figuring out the objectives, goals, timings and predictions about the long term outcome of the dialogue. We discussed Somalia and its place in the regional and international geopolitics; the regional and foreign countries scramble for Somali waters and Somalia’s not so hidden resources as part of the overall rivalry on the Indian Ocean between the conventional and emerging powers. We discussed the issues with maturity and pragmatism. We analyzed the internal challenges exiting in Somaliland and those facing Somalia; we argued about the prospects of Somaliland remaining as a separate entity and the practical need to revive the Somali unity in the face of an unabashed foreign greed that is bent on dismembering Somalia in order to make it easier for them to swallow it in pieces.

We revisited the recent history of Somalia and wisely diagnosed the root causes of the Somali tragedy. We didn’t condemn or condone any party, indeed none of us showed any intransigent positions on any of the issues we discussed. This is one of the rare times I experienced a group of diversified Somalis discussing the Somali issue in all its weird trajectories and complexities with such maturity, flexibility and pragmatism. In fact anybody who listened to us would have had the impression that we were a group of like-minded members having a working lunch on a common project.

If this cordial meeting can show anything, it shows that after being inebriated for more than 20 years in mayhem, chaos, unnecessary hostility and suspicion, Somalis have sobered up and have realized that clannism and ghetto mentality will only prolong the suffering of the Somali people and kept us an easy prey for the hounds waiting to gnash the flesh of our nation.

We, the small group of professionals, have agreed at our lunch that our real concern should not be whether to keep the cake intact or divided but to ensure that we have a cake first. And with this solemn agreement, the waiter severed us a warm and deliciously looking Afghani cake.

It is noteworthy to mention, however, that the day was 1st July, the 52nd anniversary of the Independence of Italian Somaliland and its unification with British Somaliland. I am not sure whether we had conveniently forgotten it as a topic of contention that might have spoiled the harmony that prevailed in our meeting or that it just has slipped our minds as we have been carried away by the hot plate of politics.

Bashir Goth

bsogoth@yahoo.com
Source:http://hanua.blogspot.com/

July 2, 2012

By

Tags: , , , , , , ,


Readers Comments (13)

  1. Hirsi says:

    I must say this is a good sign. Im non isaaq whoms from hargiesa. I wish we all unite. We should, we have to, we must heal each others wounds. Lets start from the Madhibaan and Gabooye.

  2. Kayse says:

    Excellent article. How can you divide or unified something that doesn't even exist. Let's first heal the wounds and respect everyone's own voice then we will draw the borders of HAA to Somalia or Haa to Somaliland.

    Let's admit, Somalia is a failed nation on life-support where there are more foreign troops than its own.

    And that Somaliland is just an isolated world with no fundamental principles. Based on a flawed concept.

  3. Ogiye says:

    We are not slicing anything. The Somali cake will remain one for the one Somali nation and its one people. Anyone who disagrees should move out.

  4. Abdiwahab says:

    somaliland must be a separate country based on the borders we inherited from the british in june '60 no other solution is acceptable simple as

  5. Reer-Dunbuluq says:

    @Kayse,

    Somaliland's case is based on solid principles: reverting back to the statutes it attained in June 1960. And this is the wishes of the majority of the Somaliland people, pure and simple. Thank God, I don't have to go through the reasons why the Somaliland people chose to reclaim their lost Independence.

    Djibout jumped off the Somaliweyn boat and you and your friends don't seem to mind. However, to you and your anti-Somaliland camp, Somaliland is a totally different ball game – historicity at its best on your part. You don't (because you can't) provide coherent and convincing arguments against Somaliland's decision, instead you just howl and bark on the top your voices Somaliland this, Somaliland that gibberish.

    If you have a bone of contention with Silanyo (or his clan), that is between you and him. Silanyo is not Somaliland, nor Somaliland is Silanyo, you need to differentiate the two.

  6. Dhugtame says:

    Coming back to the subject, Khatumo and Puntland are now out of the picture. Khatumo guys will have no choice but to come home to Somaliland.

    In Somalia politics; all Somalilanders, digil iyo Midhifle and Haweye, I mean the totality of 3.5 will vote for Sheikh Sharif for Somalia Presidency and in turn the Sheikh Shariif will support Somaliland Sovereignty. How did I come to this conclusion? Because Sheikh Sharif will have no choice since 90% of his future parliament are in support of Somaliland Sovereignty and Mr. Haglatoje, the founder of SSC has already accepted to come to Hargeisa, where he naturally belongs.

    People have seen the outcome of Da*ood leadership for the last 52-years and have no stomach for installing one or a close ally anymore.

    do you guys now see the jigsaw puzzle coming together? Do you want to hear more proof?

    here its: Sheikh Shariif has endorsed Mr. Abdillahi Osoble Siyaad's plan, which calls for two state solution. Do you want to hear and see that? just go to Hadhwanaagnews and find the audiovisual statement by Sheikh Shariif.

    Now how does Faroole feel? I think sick KKKKKK!

  7. Kayse says:

    @ Dhugtame

    Xaglatoosiye is just one individual, if he joins Hargeisa he joins them for his own gains or reasons and it might not even last. However Sool and Buhoodle township will remain opposed to Somaliland and let me say Sool minus Ainaba and as for Sanaag there are no SSC supporters. Its mainly Isaaq and Warsangeli and neither support the tribal SSC and their fake claims.

    Sool consisting of Las Anod, Tukaraq and Taleex as well as the other minor villages support Khaatumo while Buhoodle is all SSC even though its one small town claiming three regions where one doesn't even exist and the other two it doesnt control.

    SSC/Khaatumo are even worse than the Somaliland project.

    But to say they will join because Saleban is on board is just a wild dream.

    You are lucky if tonight HY doesn't declare its Maroodi Jeeh, Oodweyne, Sanaag, Hawd as their own Hawdland.

    Tribal things never last.

    • Abdi12345 says:

      Keyse,

      You are odd one out here. Tell me what is exactly wrong with you, you seem not to even able to understand the simple dynamics of Somaliland-Somalia politics. But yet, you stupidly comment on every subject.

      Get a real job and get off the computer!!!

  8. Kid Carlito says:

    In this article it seems that Bashir Goth is calling for the status quo to remain whereby Somaliland remains unrecognized and developing and Somalia tries to get back on its feet.

    To be honest as Somalilander I want Somalia to find its feet but Somaliland will NEVER EVER rejoin the union, Period!!!!

  9. rules of the game says:

    I was born in Afgooye, and left the country at the age of 10. Today I am 30 years old college graduate. Even though, I am not from Somaliland, I have been talking with friends moving their and invest because of being peaceful. However, lately I am noticing the people of Somaliland transforming into deep nationalism beyond the government and the peoples control. This type of behavior and social identity of an individual “in group” has important behavioral consequences. Its okay and normal that Somaliland seeks independence, yet, it is important that they cautious how the society process information, how they think of others. Not all people are the same. Your opinions, attributions, expectations, attitudes all reflects how outsiders view you. So please stop insulting individual and kinfolks, and focus your progress.
    Take this as advice, not complain or some of unschooled person might say, “stop crying’ all I want is my Muslim brothers to be happy and think broader and not to forget the “rules of the game”
    Thank you

  10. Cigaal says:

    Its sad that we cannot have an honest discussion without offending others or being careful not to offend or let me say calling our opponent a name, I agree with Keyse that we don't even have a cake to divide. Somalia is a failed State as a whole full of warlords and pirates. Look at these two so called leaders, Sharif was a Shabaab member before finding a place to rest and turning his back on his own friends, Silaanyo was a rebel leader that does not even respect some of his own people. We need new leaders that has no blood on their hands to decide wether we divide this dying cake into two or one.

  11. Ahmed A says:

    Mr. Goth, where was the other Cake?

  12. helyey18 says:

    You guys do argue with fools or Doqon like Kayse, as they say:
    "Never argue with a fool; onlookers may not be able to tell the difference."


You must be logged in to post a comment.

More in Opinions (341 of 848 articles)
Somalia and Somaliland meet for the first time in twenty-one years in Dubai, UAE