October 27, 2011 · 20 Comments
The Economist Magazine, in its October 1st, 2011 issue (Democracy in sub-Saharan Africa; It is progress, even if it is patchy), lauded the spread of democracy in Africa in the last decade. In the same article the Economist also listed the peaceful and democratic ousting of several ruling parties by the opposition parties. In the same the article it also mentioned President Ahmed Mohamoud Silanyo and Somaliland 4th in a list of 34 heads of states and countries that underwent peaceful and democratic change of guard. This is an honour for President Ahmed Mohamoud Silanyo; a statesman who many expect to change the politics of the region. It also included Somaliland; a country which rose like a phoenix, from the ashes of a destructive civil and became a beacon of hope for a region mired in tragedy.
In another development worth mentioning, President Silanyo’s recent visit to the eastern regions of the republic was another commendable and successful step. He extended a peaceful political hand to both the traditional and political representatives of the Sool and Sanaag regions. This step is expected to be the foundation for the success of the Taleex meeting scheduled to take place around the end of this year. The initial signs coming out from the community show that the majority of the region’s leadership is willing to establish peaceful co-existence within the sovereign boundaries of Somaliland.
The resulting outburst from an official from Puntland who opposed the Taleex meeting further attests to those regions resolute decision to take their future in their hands, sideline many self-serving detractors especially from Puntland and discount many eastern region politicians who manipulated the regions politics to their own interest. The presidents’ visit also discredited the opposition’s recent unfound claims of the governments’ collusion with Mogadishu and the UN envoy to Somalia.
But, despite these successful measures by President Ahmed Mohamoud Silanyo and his government, we must not overlook the recent blunders of his administration. How it managed both the relief aid to Somalia and the scholarships from Turkey was a political fiasco. Both incidents created a public relations nightmare for the president which forced him to further blunder (the UF word fiasco) in defence of his government’s actions.
The government either lacked political foresight or delegated the task of managing the aid to Somalia to inept officials who bungled it. By also appointing the well-known and respected Somali poet, Hadrawi, the administration was either naïve about clan-oriented implications or decided to disregard the sensibilities of the populace. Despite his fame as a literary icon among all Somalilanders, Mr, Hadrawi, is also known for his pro-unionist political views and is a staunch support the Pan-Somali irredentist ideology of the past; a view which sadly contradicts the aspirations of his country and the inviolability of its’ sovereignty.
In a similar disregard, the government showed lack of political prudence by how it handled the Turkish scholarship. It showed a lack of public relations foresight by allowing the Somaliland students nominated for the Turkish scholarship program to depart from Mogadishu, a public relations blunder which translated to a propaganda boon for the TFG in Mogadishu. The government could have opted to pay the groups’ airfare direct to Ankara to sidestep the political minefields of Mogadishu. The scandal was further exacerbated by President Silanyo’s radio interview in response to the opposition’s claim that his government is in cahoots with the United Nations Somalia Representative, Ambassador Augustine Mahiga who recently visited Hargeisa. It is not a secret that Ambassador Mahiga’s mandate is to re-establish a unified Somalia, an agenda he never deviated from in all his political briefings, community meetings and press releases since his appointment in June 2011 by the UN Secretary General Ban Ki-Moon as his Special representative for Somalia.
Therefore, to overcome the population’s pesky mistrust of the issue which is often misused by the opposition, the government must adopt and publicise a transparent and coherent foreign policy towards Mogadishu. In addition to its often stated mantra “The Holiness of Sovereignty”, the administration must also publicly state all the issues which need cooperation with Mogadishu as required by the UN in its Somaliland/Somalia mandate. Then only it will gain the unequivocal support of the people.
The administrations shortcomings and public relations disappointments are further aggravated by the continuous stream of public misgivings. The emergence of powerful financial and political cabal form within the Presidents inner circle and family is a continuous debate among Somalilanders. Many claim that President Ahmed Mohamoud Silanyo is not living up to his election promise of curbing nepotism in the political and financial matters of the government.
While in the opposition, the president often accused the last government of Dahir Riyale of corruption and blatant nepotism. Kulmiye often pointed to Dahir Riyale’s close family members who wielded a powerful influence over the treasury, the administration of high level appointments, and local and foreign investors. As a result, the majority of the public who voted for President Silanyo in the last presidential election were expecting the end of this practise and many are now disheartened by the current allegations favouritism which created a noxious atmosphere that is over shadowing the many other progressive measures implemented by the president.
This is more crucial now more than ever due to the recent political and economic developments in the region. The Saudi and other Middle Eastern governments are now willing to reopen the import of Somali livestock to their markets. According to the United Nations Food and Agricultural Organization, Saudi Arabia imports $250 million worth of Somali livestock for the Hajj period, the lion’s share from Somaliland. This number is expected to rise to $500 million a year by 2013 when the Saudi market is opened throughout the year for Somali imports. Lebanon, India and other Middle Eastern countries who already ordered initial shipments are also expected to increase its livestock imports from Somaliland.
Ethiopia is also expected to join the energy-producing countries soon. Its gas production which is expected to go online soon is expected to be shipped through the Berbera corridor in Somaliland. Many in Somaliland expect that President Mohamoud Ahmed Silanyo negotiated a profitable deal in his last trip to China where the Ethiopians were finalizing the project’s requirements. But how it will be managed is another issue.
Both developments, if properly managed, are expected to drastically increase Somaliland’s revenues; a shift that could potentially play a major role in the economic development of many sectors in Somaliland. But the current claims that allege the spread of favouritism among the President’s inner circle and family could be a detrimental factor that could potentially derail the expected benefits of both enterprises. The exclusion of local businessmen and merchants from these and other profitable government contracts is also a guaranteed precursor to social unrest that could derail the country’s peace and security.
The President, at the beginning of his term, showed the will to curb corruption by appointing Engineer, Mohamed Hashi to the Ministry of Finance. The president was lauded for this since Mr. Hashi is known for his financial integrity and no-nonsense approach in stamping out corruption from the public sector.
But now, that the stakes are higher, many hope the President would show his grit and integrity, clear allegations of nepotism from his doorstep and silence many discredited politicians who failed at the ballot box.
Mohamed Doaleh
Democracy Action Group-SL
October 20th, 2011
(Democracy Action Group-Somaliland is non-governmental non-profit organization dedicated to the promotion and upholding of democracy in Somaliland. The group will soon publish quarterly reports on the situation in Somaliland).
Email this story
By Mo Guled
Who's to blame for all the problems in this Article..The President or the Ministries designated
for such tasks???. The Presidency high command(Madaxtooyada) as a general policy as always
gives full confidencie and complete powers to his Govt. to routinely handle the day to day tasks of the Executive duties in an orderly fashion to meet and satisfy the required standard procedures to serve the Nation.Those Ministeries who failed to be upto the task must in fact solely take the blame. I also think accusing the President Silaanyo of nepotism is not fully justified. Raising the question of nepotism, this problem is all over the Regions of JSL and these cheap shots of accusing the President for such things must be generalised and thoroughly dealt with accordingly in a lawful manner. Nowadays Engineer Xaashi
is under extreme criticism for nepotism and incompentence as well!…???.
Cheers.
That's very good analytic report of the government current progress and set-backs.Silaanyo administration must do their best to eliminate corruption and nepotism.I believe that Silaanyo administration is doing their best in the tough Horn of Africa region.
I'm not sure of Silaanyo's inner circle and family members involvement in corruption, although that is a possibility. however, one thing is certain, Mr. Silaanyo is neither known for corruption or nepotism. This is proven by his long historical track record in Somali Republic and Somaliland politics.
To be fair, the Somalia humanitarian assistance went well and was a PR fiasco rather than a political disaster for Somaliland's foreign policy.
Regarding the scholarships: this was a nightmare, this was mismanaged by the minister of education from day one, when she started the process with nepotism, lied to the public by saying that government paid US $ 17000 worth of air fair and sent the kids direct to Ankara, we woke the next morning and found our kids in Mogadishu not in Ankara. I think If Silaanyo made mistake its that he did not fire her immediately.
I am sure that no one would ever wish his daughter or son to be sent to the same college our students from Somaliland were sent to in order to continue their education in Turkey. I think the idea of just going any where abroad for study on scholarship shadowed the very poor education the students are bound to receive in that college in particular. The education those students sent to donot include any of faculties medicine, engineering, agriculture, vetenary, technology, informatica. This college offers mere cultural and historical education such as: Turkish language and culture, Turkish history, sharia. Nothing more than that. Even Turkish stduents avoid that college, because they know it is a copy of Lumamba University which existed in Moscow, during the Soviet Union era, where failed students from the third world came to to sleep.
عفوا !! كاتب المقال يجهل تاريخ أرض الصومال وشعبها
English matey English
Barre, leave the guy alone. Perhaps, this is the language he speaks. And if you want to know what he said, : " Excuse me! The author of the topic is underestimating the history of Somaliland and its poeple".
ok Gobaad goch yaaa
Sorry Mate Yussef
Ciid mubaarak wa minal caaydiin yaa akh yusef. macal asaf laa yawigad laday dabaaca bil carabi wa ilaa kunuti radayt calyk bil carabi. Aaasif jidan inak tiftakair banu la tawjed laday taariikh ardhana. fikrak basidda: kunt minal muasisiin alshabaab bi jeddah xin tamal iclaan bitasiss SNM wa bacdaha asasst majalah ikhbaariya siriya macaa 4 ikhwan lifashel xukuunat altaaqiya barre. Wa min dhimn almuassisiin macaaya kaan alakh cabdilaahi jamac (xaaliyan waziir al tharwa al baxriya fi Hargeisa.
Wa limaziid minal macluumat mmkin alitisaal bicinwaan: mdoaleh@yahoo.com.
PS: Laa xaraj and every body is free to give an opinion for the common good of our beloved-bilaad arthal sowmaal. I am also min cadan, darast bi masr wa sudaan wa ashtaqalt bi jeddah min 1976 xataa 1989 wa xaaliyan muqiim bi Ottawa, Canada
PuntlandGeezer In Hargeisa
today i am in Northern somalia aka Hargeisa, hargeisa is surly a beautiful city, just lyk all the rest of mama somalia, the down side is i dnt see the beautiful flag of mama somalia anywer. anywaiz i be staying in hargeisa for a few days then hit the road to eastern regions of Las Anod den me home town of Bari & see me dad & the rest of me familys. OH & if i do find a beautiful reer issaq chick i will surely tied the knot & bring her with me to Bari lol.
Good for you buddy enjoy the formidable hospitality of Hargeisa un-lyk all the rest of turbulent mama Somalia.
As for the beautiful reer Isaaq chick lol why not as long as she's safe and sound in the hands of a real
responsible human being different than the filthy PuntlandGeezer lol
Cheers.
if in safe hands, more like she will be locked in a kitchen or so if this is the same geezar. I think we need to put a warning sign in hargaisa 'Ladies beware' kkkk
Welcome to Somaliland buddy and let the green, white and red flag dazzle your eyes
and enjoy your holiday, our funny foe lol
I think it is a good, balanced topic and a fair and constructive criticism that the President should pay attention and learn from 'xanta' dibedda or outside his circle gossip and act upon it.
This was an article that was thoroughly researched and also well written. Everyone has a right to their opinion and with that being said we need to critisize constructively and hope to benefit from one another. This article was neither written with malice or hatred towards the tribe our beloved President belongs to. We should hope to understand that Somaliland's legitamacy as a nation isn't in question, but rather to hold our elected officials to be accountable and make sure they fulfill the promises they made to the people, thus its only natural that we question certain actions made by the political elite and expect a response not because its merely our perogative but our democratic right.
Whatever this Article thoroughly researched, it's my convictions that Somaliland is full of incompentence
nepotism and corruption malpractices in almost everything a big time National recourse with almost
non existent underdog accountability agencies to control such events. You talk as JSL is really advanced
country. Let's be realistic within the means and characteristic nature of the local prevalent situations
and use simplistic approaches to different problematic identified area(s) instead of unnecessarily
compounding matters to wrong areas etc.
Cheers.
Don't get confused the big time hurdle is the poor Salaries of the Govt. Employees which's
responsible for almost the countries ills in all areas.
Cheers.
PunlandGeezer why you dont say Somaliland city Hargeysa rather than Northern Somalia since you enjoying under the peacefull Somalilnad flags and its people hospitality as you mention of its beauty city and people,,, enjoy staying Mate
Puntlandgoose.
I wish you happy and nice holiday in Somaliland. You better watch your back when you go down to Puntland, some pirates or Faroole militias might take interest in you. I hope we hear from you while you are in Puntland. Be frank and let us know you are treated over there.
Presumably PuntlandGeezer is from Las Canod not Faroole MJ Militia? kkkkkkk.
Cheers.
Ciid wanaagsan dhamaan walaaha fikradooda ka dhiibtay maqaalkan aan soo qoray. It is true that a vibrant, constructive and free debate is the nourishment of a healthy democracy. We have to also accept the maxim "it is the message not the messenger that matters. We have to avoid to be restrained by the ghost-like chains imposed by idealogy, calnnism, nepotism and the ever present human nature of accepting all and every thing for personal interest. Pls see also the articl in which I criticized UDUBs malpractise during the elections in which many wondered about my affiliation. The article is named " A Propagandist At His Worst: The Kulmiye Master Plan And Its Fallacies".
thank you
M.Muse Dualeh
mdoaleh@yahoo.com