Africa

Egypt could strike Ethiopian dam from Sudan

September 4, 2012   ·   37 Comments

dam18

LONDON — Egyptian authorities fearful of a monopoly on Nile waters received agreement from Khartoum to build an airbase in Sudan, to launch attacks on Ethiopian damming facilities, claims the anonymous media outlet; Wikileaks.

Wikileaks has leaked files allegedly from the Texas-based global intelligence company, Stratfor, which quote an anonymous “high-level Egyptian source,” claiming the Egyptian ambassador to Lebanon said in 2010 his nation would do anything to prevent the secession of South Sudan because of the political implications it will have for Egypt’s access to the Nile.

The Nile is vital in providing fresh water to the people and agricultural projects of Egypt. Also in the Nile Basin and reliant on its waters are Sudan, Eritrea, Ethiopia, Uganda, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Rwanda, Kenya, Tanzania and Burundi.

As Egypt is at the end of the river it is a particularly politically precarious situation.

Ethiopia’s planned massive hydroelectric damming project has sent shockwaves throughout the region, highlighting the faults in previously-signed treaties on Nile-sharing.

The Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam will be Africa’s largest hydroelectric facility and will be built 40km upstream from Sudan on the Blue Nile.

Ethiopia has denied Egypt’s requests to inspect the dam, unless it relinquishes its veto on water allocation. Although, according the source, Ethiopia has agreed not to use the reservoir waters for irrigation, there are concerns about the extent of water loss due to evaporation from the dam’s reservoir.

According to Wikileaks, a 2010 internal email records Sudanese president Omar al-Bashir’s agreement to host an Egyptian airbase in Kursi in the west of Sudan’s Darfur region. This base would be used to launch an Egyptian assault on the Ethiopian dam, if diplomatic efforts fail.

The anonymous source cites the “useful case-study” of Egypt’s 1976 sabotage of an Ethiopia damming project.

However, the viability of joint Sudanese-Egyptian military operations have been brought into question in light of their fractious relationship.

According to Wikileaks, the Stratfor source claimed that “if it comes to a crisis, we will send a jet to bomb the dam and come back in one day, simple as that. Or we can send our special forces in to block/sabotage the dam.”

Although they agree upon the Nile Basin Treaty, the contested Halayed Triangle, in 2010, to Bashir accusing Egypt of occupying Sudanese territory.

The immediacy and extent of the Ethiopian threat to Egyptian freshwater access is questionable but its domestic political usefulness for the now ousted Mubarak regime is not.

The continued political application of the Ethiopian threat is, allegedly, now being exerted on the incumbent government by the Muslim Brotherhood.

On 26 August Egypt denied allegations that the new government is under pressure to persuade key regional investor, China, to not back such Nile development programmes.

The UN estimates that by 2050 the world’s population will have increased by 3.5 billion, with the majority of the growth in developing countries where water stress is already in key issue, potentially making access to freshwater more incendiary than access to fossil fuels in the coming decades.

Although Egypt was a perennial economic underachiever during the Mubarak regime’s years of mismanagement, it has the potential to be a powerhouse. This makes its need to secure future access to resources all the more important and potentially domineering.

Sudan Tribune

September 4, 2012

By

Tags: , , , , , ,


Readers Comments (37)

  1. abdu says:

    hi are you talking about egypt dream or fantasy

  2. abdu says:

    egypt is in day dream

  3. Julian says:

    A Wikileaks cable on Ethiopia indicated the regime in Ethiopia bombed its own people numerous times and blamed it on the opposition group.

    I wouldn’t be surprised if the regime also bombs the dam to blame it on Egypt.

  4. haile says:

    if egypt bomb the dam we put nuclear wast on the Nile flow as simple as such because Nile flow from Ethiopia via Sudan to egypt not visversa

  5. Oromo says:

    i hope egypt not just bombs the dam but also makes the country split up into mini fiefdoms which will give hope for the whole of northeast africa

  6. Henok says:

    Egypt bombing one of ethiopian dam maynot seem true. but if it is, i assure u its gonna b a hell of a war. and egypt is not gonna face the 200,000 ethiopian soldiers. they r gonna have a war with 90,000,000 ETHIOPIAN people. not any people ETHIOPIAN, and belive me, that is a war the egyptians wont even wanna imagin, a war they will loose.

  7. heron says:

    I don't think so that the Egyptian gov"t will repeat the history of loose that propagate by Sadat if they percieve that ethiopia is as wesk as the past. we are strong interms of economic and military. !!

  8. Badohabenta says:

    If Egypt tries those claims, I assure you that things would turn out to be real hell. I recommend Egypt not to mess with Ethiopia. She [Egypt] better finishes it on the table rather than going for blow up the dam. I do believe that Egypt won't go for that anyways.

  9. Kayse says:

    Egypt doesn't need to waste money on Ethiopia. First of all this project will never materialise and secondly, Ethiopia is set to break up into many ethnic and religion regions.

    Egypt should invest its money wisely instead of wasting money on Ethiopia and their propaganda dam.

    • @iueae says:

      It is suicide to try to attache Ethiopia. Consequences:
      - destroying the dam will be followed by destroying another dam.
      - poisoning of the water.
      - use Tana as a dam after this. Just divert the river at each and every tribute to irrigation. Use Tana with full potential – no additional dam is required. Full stop.

      Finally Egypt will be the loser.

      One more thing, Meles said “Egypt won’t win the war”. Egypt said in response “We never talked about war”. Wikileaks said they did actually talked and Ethiopian gov’t intelligence knows about it before wikileaks even releases the report. Well done Ethiopia!

  10. aw sugule says:

    i don't agreed of dire of egypt it's pretention!!!
    i think that the reality is egypt is pretentious and baster because it not doubt that the water of the nil is ouwner of the people of ethiopia and don't think that egypt is any word to say of this item
    so if egypt and sudan be allied it's clear that they do no weight ethiopia because ethôpia is strong air force and military than the two allies
    i hate arab and ethiopia and i am proud to be the somalilander

  11. aw sugule says:

    error i like ethopia people because we have many things commons if we are the somalilanders and we are for ever being same people and one destiny beacause one region horn of africa

  12. Mogadishu says:

    I think egypt will strike Ethiopian Dumb and i hope they will do that in the near future.
    We give the Egyptians the greenlight to finish this job once for all.Long Live The Land Of The Pharoahs.

    • Ibrahimm says:

      you have the right to dream while you are still wake. time will tell you. I hope you know very well who we are and we have never be against any one but we have the right to be beneficiary on win win situation. we will see if your dream will materialize and try to be yourself.

  13. Jabuutawi says:

    Any nation that finds itself in an existential threat like Egypt has two choices: Either acquiesce to the status quo and let Ethiopia build a dam on the Blue Nile, or do what any other country would do and ensure the viability of its society by going to war for free access to the Nile's water.

    Ethiopia is in an untenable position – tactically they KNOW they are no match for Egypt's vast military superiority and the foregone conclusion that they are unable to wage any sustainable and meaningful push back. Egypt has time and demographics on its side; Ethiopia is disintegrating from within and all indications point to in the next 2 to 4 years that it will cease to exist. New emerging nations with their own aspirations and hopes take afoot from the ashes of what once was an illusionary empire.

    To correct few misconceptions held by some of the bloggers: Dropping radioactive isotopes into the water will not make Ethiopia any safer. The land will become terra non grata for generations and the indigenous peoples will rise up against their government. Secondly, do not assume all Ethiopians will come to the defense of patchwork of a nation held together by the few with guns who subjugate the many and unwilling. The Afars, the Oromos, the Southern Nations, etc. want no part of the central government in Addis Ababa.

    Lastly, I would be remiss not to mention that the Afars and the Oromos are divided among many clans and are not cohesive units. Northern Afars don't care much for the Southern Afars, hence, no one region would come to the rescue of another region should civil war breakout. It is total fallacy to think the Afars are one clan – they are not. They are one ethnic group with many clans within. The notion that once the Afars form a nation they will reclaim lands beyond Ethiopia proper is a ludicrous statement. They don't have the capacity to do so.

    • hornid says:

      Jabuutawi u seem so certain about " unity " people of Djibouti. Your country face also same problem than many african countries as most of Afar djiboutian want to secede from your north territory and many other somalis ( Issaq, Samaroon, Daroods) except ur Issa clan want either to join Somaliland or re create dream of Great Somali with 5 regions. Personally, I think if Djibouti decide to join Somali republic as it was supposed to be then Somaliland will be less reluctant to join South.

      • Gedi says:

        Jabuutawi is a cursed individual who likes nobody! He hates all the neighbors of Djibouti. Do you know why? He surrendered himself to a western country as a Somali refugee and now he's playing only with his own belly. Jabuutawi is a useless guy, so don't waste your valuable times with him.

      • libban says:

        hahahaahh Daroods in Djibouti hahahaahh what a joke. there is only Dir Somalis in Djibouti

    • Defar says:

      If Egypt tries to attack any electric facility on Nile, jabutawi should be the first to revenge. Why? Simple. U r one of the beneficiary from Nile river. Don't forget our power grids are interconnected.

      • Jabuutawi says:

        There is no appreciable difference for the average Djiboutian when it comes to electricity, dam or no dam. Djibouti would like to directly deal with the "new" government forming in the newly formed state where the dam is located. I have no qualms with all the ethnic groups in Ethiopia forming their own countries, and look forward to visiting all 10 countries in the old Ethiopia. I don't mind visiting you in your neck of the woods as a tourist hailing from West-Somalia.

        • Defar says:

          Sorry, I wouldn't respond to u if I knew u r tribal or clannish. On my side I need think of the region, horn even further to Egypt. We r tired of narrowness and poverty. Our region deserves more than what we r in.

    • Arsema says:

      those who speak against GOD are those who are cursed!! and GOD gave his word, Egypt should fail under GOD's foot for forgiveness but his word is inevitable. GOD did miracles and he will do so and every creation will obey that he is GOD.

  14. Ahmed Nur says:

    Egypt verses Ethiopia. The Nile is a blessed river flowing from Ethiopia to Egypt. That has a deep meaning. If Egypt tries to interfere with the Nile and tries to destroy it then they have themselves to blame. Ethiopia is an ancient and blessed land. Prophet Muhammad(scw) also blessed Ethiopia sending them peace prayers. Somaliland has long ties with Ethiopia and peace is the link that ties these two neighbourly nations.

    Somaliland though a muslim nation is different to the other muslim countries. Somehow a lot of muslim nations have adopted the Wahabi and its sister Salafi ideologies. The Salafi related people hate peace and are always at war with peaceful nations trying to create their own states. That is why a lot of Arabs are in crisis at present. They forgot the essence of peace. Declaring war on peaceful Christian nations is not the solution in this day and age.

    Finally, it is not possible in this day and age for Egypt to bomb Ethiopia, totally impossible.

  15. WANLAWYN says:

    Egypt will probably get 1 million Somali volunteers to fight this war. Ethiopia in trouble means somalias survival as ethiopia said in their foreign policy statement.

    http://somalilandpress.com/ethiopian-policy-revea

  16. Habesha says:

    Firs of all the Egyptian themselves didn't think about war. We Ethiopians only want peace and development. we know the impact of war for 3000 years. so this hydroelectric project uses not only Ethiopia but also for the horn of Africa (Kenya,Djibouti,Somalia,Somaliand, sudan and Egypy

    I assure we built this dam and memorize to our late PM Meles Zenawi.

  17. this is just funy.

  18. alnugomi says:

    There is no region in Darfur or anywhere in Sudan called "Kursi", please double check that…

  19. mohamed cheers says:

    Ethiopias strong policy maker Ato Meles Zenawi is dead and the new PM would be battling
    between now uptill 2015 with so many other political affairs diverting his focus on the River
    nile project. Ethiopia coping up many other political issues, can not afford to add more wars
    with Egypt at least for a good meanwhile years to come. Besides, Ethiopia is the headquarters
    of the AU Continent and should play a good clandestine host to the AU World. Egypt too,
    in Similar situation, have just recently through the Arab Spring uprisings, changed from Military
    dictatorship into Civilian Muslim Brotherhood democratization type Governance which keeps
    Egypt busy both inside and outside to battle against many problems that would not encourage
    for the new Islamic Egypt to go for Military wars with Ethiopia or the M-E etc. Therefore, in the
    interests of peaceful co-existence and to spare more chaos of the AU Continent, these two
    ancient countries should show diplomatic resilience to prevai over all issues.
    Cheers.

  20. mohamed cheers says:

    typo: Prevail…not prevai.
    Cheers.

  21. Hargeisa citizen says:

    First of all I'd like to say that neither Egypt nor Ethiopia is ready for war, because both countries are dealing with political transitions as of the second half of 2012, secondly Egypt would never take a step that would sabotage the health of the millions of people living in the Nile basin simply because it is a stupid move that would degrade Egyptian image internationally, Ethiopia is a major denomination of the Christian faith and Egypt is a very powerful Muslim country compared to Ethiopia hence the western countries would never allow the two parties to go to war together, Ethiopia is facing a major internal political conflicts both racial and regional thus making engaging in a international dispute something far away from the table, all in all the whole dam issue will be resolved in a peaceful manner i believe.

  22. Tatek says:

    IS this a kind of psychological war let Alon now even in old days Ethiopian has never lost war ASK YOUR ITALIAN FRIENDS. i don't think this is a football game it is WAAAAARRRRRRR

  23. ibrahimmoamin says:

    bombing the dam ? What a siliy idea ! Let them try and face the out come which is diverting the flow of Nile to another direction . For sure Sudan will not be so un-matture to to give airspace for them for the pesose of bombing the dam b/c the late meles gave vast border (between 30-50 km deep to Ethiopia) area to Sudan and had an agreement to not be lounching pad for the 3rd party as well as harbouring domestic opositions. Not only this The Egyptians are the one who suport the curent gov. To come in to power and now they want to bomb the dam ? So silly and funy ! Any ways time will tell .

  24. dantef says:

    I don’t think Ethiopia will sleep,when egypt bark by her plain,world knows the power of God,Mubarek also dismissed by power of God,Previousely ,I wrote to Mubarek,to rais his hands from Ethiopia three years ago,I copy the letter to BBC news,it is true, I would like to tell Brother hood,to stop Undeveloped idea to attak blood of Ethiopia,we thought them in 1867 but we didnt believe in by force but we can thought them how to play the game of war!!

  25. Mekonnen says:

    Ex-prime Minister was always calculating political games on how to run with American external affairs and there by assure American funds on terrorism in many dimensions. I think, perhaps the worest mistake Meles Zenawi did in his appeasement policy was his blind decission to build a hydro electric power over blue nile. For me Ethiopia is not astable country, internally divided, a people oppressed by manority rule,claiming further political rights, a country can be cited as a good example of internal colonization, can not impliment this huge project as they intended in a very easy and feasible way.
    First of all it creats a condusive political athmospher for armed opponents. For Egypt instead of bombing the Dam , it is easy to organize opposition groups who need the support of regional countries especially Sudan.

  26. zzz says:

    TRY -We shall show All our strength !!!

  27. Ahmad says:

    Guys I am Egyptian and I am sure Egypt will never do such a thing, We believe each country has the right to live a better life, we will never think in such stupid things. peace

  28. belay says:

    Ethiopia isn't in internal racial &regional conflict.rather it is stable &acounty w/h struggles against dangerous enemy poverity. Ethiopia is not war outbreaker in its history but if thre is offensive we don know heistate. now we are asking them to leave thier blind veto on Nile &we call them to grow togehter hand in hand by using the common resource commonly.If they heistate &come to WAR we will show them our effort.


You must be logged in to post a comment.

More in Africa (114 of 1003 articles)
Somalilanders pay tribute to Meles, who contributed greatly to the region.